Search This Blog

Like GFM On Facebook

Copyright 2012 Grimm Factor Music. Powered by Blogger.

Categories

Total Pageviews

April 23, 2012
That's A Great Question!

The answer?...I think you should understand what it takes for your music to make an impact. That understanding comes from knowledge, resources, time, patience, and a little trial and error. Whenever an artist asks me for feedback about their music, I give them that. Feedback. Not the kind of feedback a fan would give, but the kind I would give. Constructive feedback.

See, in my mind, I believe every human being on this planet possesses natural creative talents. We all tap into that talent in various ways. All musicians have talent, just some are more tapped into that creative well than others. I believe as musicians we should be there for each other constructively, offering insight and experience to help our fellow musicians along. Its a sure sign of support.

this post will go over some questions I ask myself when hearing new music,



Grimm's Songwriter Breakdown

1.) Title - Actually, this is usually the last thing I consider because the content of a song may have nothing to do with the actual title. 
  • When considering song titles I look to see if it has any relevance to the lyrical content and in what way. 
  • Does the title stand out? 
  • Does it connect with me at all?
  • Does it seem too? Too vague? Too Specific? Or just right? 
  • Am I thinking too much about the title or not enough? 
  • What was the artist thinking when they came up with the title of the song?
  • Is there anything about the title that would hold back exposure?
2.) Usually, I take in all of the song before breaking it down. I listen passively before listening actively. What's really cool to me is if the song makes me listen to it over and over again. When I say the song makes me listen over and over, I mean that. A piece of my active listening skills creep in here and there

So in the interest of lyrics I ask myself things like:
  • What mood or feelings are these lyrics supposed to convey? 
  • Just like the title are the lyrics too cliche or generic? Too Vague? Too Descriptive? 
  • Do the lyrics serve a purpose or are they just written on a piece of paper? 
  • What was the songwriter's reasons for writing this song?
  •  Does it seem as though the songwriter knows what they are talking about from personal experience or someone else's? That question takes an assumptive stance. 
  • Some more questions I might ask are: Should these lyrics be rewritten? How can this song be rewritten to say the same exact thing it WAS saying but just saying it better?
  • Anything to keep this track from going far? 
3.) Arrangement - A huge part of writing is the arrangement. Think of an arrangement as being the melody to the words of a song without music. It's how the artist(s) will sing the lyrics. 

Songwriters are able to make arrangements in many possible scenarios. Tweaks are made to the music, lyrics, and/or arrangement to perfect the song. In hip hop music, rappers have arrangements to their lyrics. That arrangement encompasses style, flow, and delivery (part of the delivery is the vibe you give off). 

When I hear a songwriter's arrangement, I ask myself: 
  • What kind of tone is being set with this arrangement? 
  • Does it fit the overall feel and design of the lyrics? Meaning, if the song is supposed to be about fun, then the arrangement shouldn't make me want to cry. 
  • Is there harmony in the arrangement, and does it work? 
  • Should there be background vocals/singers? 
  • Is it in the right pitch and tone? 
  • Does it transition well from section to section? From hook to harmony and beyond.
  • What kind of tweaks, if any, would you suggest the singer make to increase the impact of the arrangement and lyrics? 
  • Can the singer handle the range needed for the song?  
  • Is this song incredible WITH OR WITHOUT music?? 
  • Am I really feeling this?
Grimm's Instrumental Breakdown

I take choosing the music I write to very seriously. I am extremely selective. Being selective doesn't mean I only stick to one style or genre of music. It just means that whatever track I choose has to connect with me on more than just the surface. There's a lot of activity in the brain as I listen to the music I plan on writing to. When it comes to music I listen to, whether actively or passively, I take the same stance, I'm very selective. Although now as a music publisher building a catalog, I have to listen to more and more music and be open to a variety of artistry, I still am extremely selective to the kind of music I will place in that catalog.

In the interest of instrumentals I ask myself these questions:
  • Does the tempo of the beat match the lyrics that are written?
  • Is the arrangement of the vocals on par with the actual beat?
  • What vibe am I getting from this beat? 
  • Can I write to the beat now, use a song I've already written, or save it till later when I'm ready to write to it? If I save the beat for later, will I still have the same reaction to it?
  • Does this beat grab me within the first 30 seconds? If so does it let me go afterwards or does the beat keep me in its clutches the whole time?
  • Is the track repetitive? Any differences in the arrangement of the beat besides a repeated riff, sample, or loop?
  • What genre is this beat designed in and can I write a song to fit that genre?
  • Is this beat right for me and my style of writing or should I forward it to someone else?
Choosing the music I write to or creating the music I write to is more of a feeling/vibe/mood based selection than anything. If the music can evoke a certain response from me the whole time I listen to it, then there's a good chance I will select that track to write to. 

Grimm's Complete Song Breakdown

Since the majority of musicians that ask me for feedback will more than likely have completed material, I forgo much of the questions asked above. They are really situation specific. In order to give feedback the way I know best, I usually pick certain questions to ask myself that work good overall. 

In the interest of listening to music that I would not only enjoy for myself but to also give feedback, I ask questions like:
  • Does this song grab me within a reasonable amount of time? Honestly if I've listened to a song for over a minute and it hasn't wrapped itself around my soul, then it may not be for me. 
  • How does this song make me feel? 
  • Can I understand the concept of the song?
  • Does the singer do a great job of making me believe in the lyrics? 
  • Does the singer do a great job of matching the arrangement to the music? 
  • Is this the right singer for this song?
  • Are the harmonies on point? The background vocals/adlibs/sound efx in the right places? 
  • Is the song at least mixed thoroughly? Can I actually listen to and enjoy the song sonically?
  • How long have I been listening to this song before deciding to critique it??
  • Do I want this song in my playlist?
  • Do I want to hear more from this artist? 
  • DO I WANT TO SUPPORT THIS ARTIST??
  • As a publisher, am I willing to reach out to this artist for a chance at cataloging their material??
These are just some of the questions I ask myself when listening to a song. I give an artist feedback on the most important aspects of my thoughts. If an artist asks me for more in-depth analysis then I'll be able to provide that.

The real testament to how I feel about your song comes when I describe it in as few words as possible. Something like: OMG YOUR SONG IS AMAZING!! 

I hope this breakdown helps my fellow musicians create great songs and compositions. Leave your thoughts about what goes through your mind when listening to music (as a musician), before giving feedback. 

0 comments: